Exploring the Return to Supplier (BMK) Scenario

Objective

After completing this lesson, you will be able to execute the end-to-end process steps of the Return to Supplier (BMK) scenario.

Introduction

Listen to consultant Julia and supply chain manager Paul as they introduce the Return to Supplier scenario in the following short dialogue.

Understanding the Difference: Supplier Return vs. Return Delivery

The supplier return (or return to supplier) process described in this scenario differs significantly from a simple return delivery to the supplier:

Supplier Return

In contrast, a supplier return is treated as a standalone process. It does not reference a specific initial procurement transaction.

The process begins with the creation of a return purchase order, followed by the goods return, and concludes with the creation of a credit memo, which transfers the liability back to the supplier.

  • Return Delivery

    A return delivery is a direct follow-up to a goods receipt for a purchase order. It is processed as a goods issue posting, with or without a delivery document, and is directly linked to the original purchase order.

    Example: Goods are returned immediately after receipt due to quality issues.

  • Supplier Return

    In contrast, a supplier return is treated as a standalone process. It does not reference a specific initial procurement transaction.

    The process begins with the creation of a return purchase order, followed by the goods return, and concludes with the creation of a credit memo, which transfers the liability back to the supplier.

    Examples of return to supplier scenarios:

    • You procure filters from a supplier and return the used filters for recycling. In return, you receive a credit note at the agreed price.

    • You have an agreement with your cable suppliers to return cable residues. You then receive a credit memo for the value of the copper contained in the cables (Paul’s scenario).

    • After a promotion or the end of a season, you return unsold merchandise to your supplier and receive a corresponding credit note.

SAP S/4HANA Cloud Public Edition offers two distinct approaches for handling returns to suppliers, depending on the complexity and requirements of the return process:

Basic Return to Supplier

To process a basic return to a supplier:

  • Use the Create Purchase Order – Advanced app and select the order type Standard PO (NB).
  • At the item level, manually set the Returns Item indicator.
  • Return items can be combined with regular order items in the same purchase order, allowing you to order and return goods simultaneously.

To post the goods return, use either of the following apps:

  • Post Goods Movement
  • Post Goods Receipt for Purchasing Document

Optionally, you can also process the return using shipping functionalities.

If shipping documents or loading lists are needed:

  • Ensure the Returns Supplier checkbox is selected in the supplier master record (under purchasing organization data).
  • Use the My Purchase Orders – Due for Delivery app to create the outbound delivery.
  • Use the Manage Outbound Deliveries app for picking and posting the goods issue.

To create a credit memo, use the Create Supplier Invoice app

Advanced Return to Supplier

For more structured returns processing:

  • Use the Create Purchase Order – Advanced app and select the order type Enh. Ret. to Supplier (NB2).
  • The Returns Item indicator is automatically set and cannot be removed.
  • Only return items are allowed in this type of purchase order - no mixing with regular items.

Using shipping functionalities for the delivery process is mandatory in this scenario.

  • Use the My Purchase Orders – Due for Delivery app to create the outbound delivery.
  • Use the Manage Outbound Deliveries app for picking and posting the goods issue.

Optionally, you can request replacement materials.

After the return, you can request a replacement material using the Receive Replacement Materials – From Vendor app. This app automatically creates:

  • A new purchase order
  • An inbound delivery for the replacement item

Next, follow up by putting away the replacement materials and posting the goods receipt for the inbound delivery.

We’ll now demonstrate the advanced process in the system.

Although Paul’s scenario doesn’t involve ordering replacements for returned cable residues, the process is still worth exploring.

Create Advanced Return Purchase Order

The first step in returning the cable residues in Paul’s scenario is to create a return purchase order.

It’s important to note that this must be done using the Create Purchase Order – Advanced app, as the specific order type required for the advanced return process is not yet supported in the Manage Purchase Orders app.

Watch the interactive demo to learn how to create an advanced return purchase order.

Create Return Delivery

Watch the interactive demo to learn how to create a return delivery with reference to a return purchase order.

Pick and Post Goods Issue

We’ll now continue with picking and goods issue. While you can use the Manage Outbound Deliveries app for this step, we’ll explore an alternative method for now. We’ll revisit the Manage Outbound Deliveries app later in other scenarios, such as subcontracting or stock transfers.

Watch the interactive demo to learn how to pick the quantity to be returned and post the goods issue.

Order Replacement Material

Now, listen to Julia as she introduces the next step in the process: requesting replacement material after a return. This is done by creating a new purchase order (replacement purchase order) that references the previously created return purchase order.

Watch the interactive demo to learn how to create a replacement purchase order.

Post Goods Receipt for Replacement Material

In the following short dialog, consultant Julia explains to goods receipt specialist Anil how the receipt of a replacement material is posted.

View the following interactive demo to learn how to post the goods receipt for the replacement material.

Optional Follow-Up Activities

In the following short dialog, Julia presents several follow-up activities that can be performed for replacement materials.

Watch the interactive demo to learn how to execute some follow-up activities.