Executing Period-End Closing Procedures

Objectives

After completing this lesson, you will be able to:
  • List typical period-end closing activities
  • Analyze projects with progress analysis
  • Perform period-end settlement

Period-End Closing Activities

James and Linda Discuss Period-End Closing

The first month of project work ends, and James, project planner at Hybrid Machinery, discusses with Linda, project controller at the same company, the required steps that have to be carried out during period-end closing.

Note

This is their conversation:

Period-End Closing Activities in the Project

Period-end closing activities include settlement, template allocation, overheads, interest calculation, cost forecasting, progress analysis, results analysis and incoming orders.

You perform period-based business transactions as a part of the period-end closing procedure. This enables you to ensure that all the data belonging to a period is determined and made available to enterprise controlling. The figure, Period-End Closing Activities, shows an overview of period-end closing activities for projects.

The various period-end closing activities are as follows:

  • Overhead costing:

    Overhead costing is used to allocate the overhead costs (in terms of percentage or quantity-based overheads) for supplied materials, machines, and labor.

  • Template allocation:

    Template allocation is another method for allocating overheads. This method does not allocate costs, but determines the quantities used by the receiver object. The costs are then calculated by valuating the quantities with a price that enables costs to be determined according to cause.

  • Project calculation:

    Interest calculation plays an important role in long-running and cost-intensive projects. In the SAP Project System (SAP PS), planned and actual interest calculation can be used to calculate and update interest.

  • Cost forecast:

    With cost forecasts, you can adjust cost planning to changing circumstances during the execution phase of a project. In a cost forecast, the system determines and valuates the remaining activities on the basis of the planned, forecast, and actual values in the network.

  • Progress analysis:

    You use progress analysis to compare the planned and actual progress of a project based on actual results.

  • Results analysis:

    Results analysis carries out a periodic valuation of projects. Data such as stock values, cost of sales, and reserves are calculated.

  • Incoming orders:

    Using the project-related incoming orders function, the system determines key figures for incoming orders and open orders from sales orders assigned to projects. This enables you to draw conclusions at an early stage regarding the anticipated result of a customer project.

  • Settlement:

    You use project settlement to allocate the costs and revenues in projects or allocate the results analysis data to one or more receivers.

Percentage of Completion

The basic concepts of progress analysis include the following:

  • Percentage of Completion (POC):
    • Specifies the project progress as a percentage.
    • Describes the ratio of activity carried out to a specific date as a percentage of total work for the activity or project.
    • Determines POC on the basis of the specified measurement method.
  • Earned Value:
    • Describes the value of work done in a project.
    • Describes the costs corresponding with the POC of a project element.

Percentage of Completion (POC) is used to determine how much progress has been made on a project. This type of analysis is common in most construction and engineering environments. By using different techniques, you can use factors other than revenue and cost planning to determine progress. However, planning is still an important factor.

To use POC, you must maintain the POC determination methods for determining your planned and actual POC for a given period. It is possible to use different methods for different objects. The system compares the progress that you should have made against your actual progress to determine your schedule variance. It also compares your actual cost to your budgeted cost of work performed, that is, how much time you should have spent to achieve your actual POC. This comparison determines your cost variance.

Earned Value Analysis

Earned Value Analysis

The Percentage-of-Completion (POC) and the earned value are important project key figures. You can analyze these at the level of individual project elements or aggregated for the whole project or sub-project. Like other project key figures, progress analysis values are available in the following report types:

A graph is shown containing lines for earned value (planned), earned value (actual) and actual costs.
  • Structure-oriented report on progress analysis
  • Drill-down hierarchy report
  • Report Painter or Report Writer reports

Planned POC: The planned POC is the value of the work planned for up to a certain point in time, expressed as a percentage of all the work required.

Actual POC: The actual POC is the value of the work done up to a certain point in time, expressed as a percentage of all the work required.

Earned Value (EV): The EV arises from the valuation of the POC and the base (for example, the cumulative planned costs or the total budget). The planned EV or Budgeted Cost of Work Scheduled (BCWS) provides the value of the scheduled work. The actual EV or Budgeted Cost of Work Performed (BCWP) provides the value of the work performed.

You can compare the planned earned value with the actual earned value to calculate the scheduling variance (SV). A positive scheduling variance means that the actual POC is lower than the planned POC so you're lacking behind your original project plan. A negative scheduling variance means that the actual POC is higher than the planned POC so your project progress is faster than originally planned.

You can compare the actual earned value with the actual costs to derive the cost variance (CV). If the actual costs are higher than the actual earned value the costs are higher than they should be according to the project plan.

You can use the structure overview to evaluate the POC and earned value. The system displays the values in line with the project hierarchy. You can use the structure overview to evaluate the POC and the earned value in the following configuration:

  • Aggregated
  • Not aggregated
  • Corrected
  • Not corrected

From the hierarchical display, you can navigate to a project object in the period breakdown and the graphical display.

Analyze the Progress of a Project

Settlement Rules

Settlement Rules

Settlement rules are required to settle the project. These rules determine which portions of sender’s costs are transferred to which cost receivers. Settlement rules are stored in the sender objects and contain distribution rules and settlement parameters. They are required to settle the project.

An example is shows of a settlement of a billing element to a profitability segment.

You can create settlement rules manually in the Project Builder. For WBS elements, you can also use the Create Settlement Rule app or the underlying transactions (CJB1 and CJB2) . Depending on predefined strategies, these transactions create settlement rules for cost centers or profitability segments, or they inherit predefined settlement rules.

When you settle your project, costs and revenues are transferred to financial accounting (G/L account), asset accounting (fixed asset), management accounting, or profitability analysis (order, cost center, and profitability segment), or the SAP PS (WBS elements, networks, and activities).

For sales projects, only the billing element is normally settled, because results analysis is carried out at the billing element level. The results analysis data contains costs and revenue not only for the billing elements, but also for all the WBS elements and activities that are subordinate to the billing elements. However, only the billing element has a settlement rule. A settlement profile, Do not settle, is assigned to all other objects.

Actual Overhead Allocation

Actual Overhead Allocation

You calculate actual overheads based on the costing sheet and overhead key you entered on the WBS element, network header, or network activity.

An example is shown of an actual overhead calculation.

Actual overhead calculation allocates cost objects with actual overheads. Overhead is allocated to cost objects using quantity-based or percentage allocation rates.

You can simulate overhead allocation (test run).

The overhead calculation process generates the following postings:

  • Overhead expenses are charged to cost objects (network activities, network header, and WBS elements)
  • The cost center (or the overhead process) is credited. Costs are updated using the secondary cost elements specified in the credit rows in the costing sheet. Actual overhead calculation uses the costing sheet entered in the cost object.

Results Analysis

Carrying out Results Analysis

Business Example

You want to use results analysis to accrue costs and revenues by period for the logistics project. Results analysis calculates reserves and balances. Use settlement to settle profit by period to profitability analysis and post reserves or balances in FI.

Overview of Results Analysis

Results analysis is a periodic process that determines the costs and revenues for a period based on planned costs and revenues and the POC.

Questions that a results analysis can answer are for example: What is the project result for the period? What current costs do I need to capitalize as WIP? Do I need reserves for imminent losses? And: Do I need reserves for costs not yet incurred?

By comparing the results from the analysis with an actual posting that was recorded previously in FI, the analysis provides a posting in FI (WIP, reserves). You can also post some results to profitability analysis to ensure that the period results in FI are the same as those recognized in profitability analysis.

The first stage of results analysis involves calculating the following values:

  • Inventory values
  • Reserves for unrealized costs
  • Reserves for imminent loss
  • Reserves for complaints/warranties and commissions
  • Cost of sales

You can settle the following to FI and Profit Center Accounting (CO-PCA):

  • Inventory values
  • Reserves for unrealized costs
  • Reserves for imminent loss
  • Reserves for complaints and commissions
  • The cost of sales if you are using non-valuated project stock and are balancing in FI with the cost-of-sales accounting method

You can settle the following to profitability analysis (CO-PA):

  • Cost of sales or calculated revenue
  • Reserves for imminent loss and complaints

Results Analysis Process

Results analysis evaluates long-term customer projects.

It determines costs and revenues that belong to earned values for a project in a given period. It can also determine work-in-process (WIP) or reserves for unrealized costs.

Results analysis calculations are based on comparing planned with actual costs and revenues based on a POC.

Results are calculated for billing elements and non-billing WBS elements with stocks of their own and assigned orders.

The POC is determined by the valuation method that you chose. You can calculate results analysis using various valuation methods and store the results in various CO versions.

Results are calculated for the following:

  • Billing elements
  • Non-billing WBS elements with stocks of their own and assigned orders, which require a separate results analysis calculation

Legend:

  • C(z): Work in progress
  • C(r): Reserves for unrealized costs
  • R(z): Revenue in excess of billings
  • R(r): Revenue surplus
  • C(p): Planned costs
  • R(a): Actual revenues
  • C(a): Actual costs
  • R(c): Revenues affecting result
  • C(c): Costs affecting result
  • POC: Percentage of completion

Results Analysis: Costs and Revenues

Results analysis calculates costs and revenues by period, with balances or reserves. Settlement settles the values it determines to a settlement receiver (usually a profitability segment).

Costs and revenues in a results analysis are shown.

If the costs that affect the result are different from the actual costs, the following scenarios may result:

  • If actual costs are greater than the calculated cost of sales for the result, the difference is posted as work in process.
  • If actual costs are less than the calculated cost of sales for the result, a reserve for unrealized costs is established.

If revenues that affect the result are different from actual revenues, the following scenarios may result:

  • If the actual revenues exceed revenues that affect the result, the difference forms a revenue surplus (unearned revenue).
  • If the actual revenues are less than revenues that affect the result, the result is called inventory, from which revenue can be generated (deferred revenue).

The results analysis method that you use depends on the constraints of your business requirements. Your business can use various processes and types of projects, and it may require various result analysis methods. The valuation method contains formulas to calculate results analysis data.

Example of Revenue-Proportional Results Analysis

When you use revenue-based methods, the revenue relevant to profit equals the actual revenue. You can use this method with milestone billing and to report intermediate profits. You must have planned costs and revenues to use this method.

The ratio of actual revenue to planned revenue determines the POC.

An example is shown of a revenue-proportional results analysis.

If you perform revenue-based results analysis according to the cost of sales method, the cost of sales is formed on the basis of actual revenues earned to date.

If actual costs are greater than the costs relevant to profit, the system creates reserves for unrealized costs.

If actual costs are less than the costs relevant to profit, the system creates reserves for unrealized costs (expenses).

If you use the revenue-based method with profit realization, the calculated cost of sales is zero as long as the actual revenue for the period is zero. Capitalized costs then equal the actual costs of the period.

The example shows the POC calculated using the ratio of actual revenues posted to date to planned revenues (POC = 40%).

You use the POC to determine the cost of sales for actual revenues (COS = 40% x planned costs = 800).

The result is an inventory balance (WIP = 200) because actual costs are greater than the calculated costs of sales. The settlement of the WIP generates the following posting in FI: Inventory (WIP) account against an inventory change account of 200.

The inventory change account is closed against the profit and loss account. The Profit and Loss sheet shows 1200 as the actual revenue on the profit side plus 200 as inventory change. On the loss side, the Profit and Loss sheet shows actual costs as 1000. Based on this posting, FI and CO-PA both show a profit of 400.

Settlement for Logistics Projects

Carrying out Settlement for Logistics Projects

Settlement Parameters

Depending on the maintenance of the settlement rule, different options exist to carry out settlement.

Settlement options are: multilevel settlement and direct settlement.

In direct settlement, you settle each object in a project (WBS elements, networks, orders, and activities) directly to a cost object not included in the project, such as a profitability segment.

In multilevel settlement, you first settle activities, orders, and WBS elements to the top WBS element in the project. The top element then settles the costs collected.

Specify which of the following you want to use when you maintain or determine the settlement rule:

  • Multilevel settlement for settlement to WBS elements of other projects or the same project
  • Direct settlement for the settlement of Project System structures to receivers outside of the project

In customer projects, you perform results analysis before settlement. Settlement only settles the objects for which results analysis has been performed (WBS elements and orders with their own WIP). Orders and WBS elements without their own WIP must have a settlement profile set to Do not settle.

Create Settlement Rules for Projects

Perform Period-End Settlement

Log in to track your progress & complete quizzes