Conducting System and User Acceptance Testing in the Realize Phase

Conducting Parallel Payroll Testing

Objective

After completing this lesson, you will be able to execute parallel payroll testing cycles to verify that SAP SuccessFactors Employee Central Payroll produces consistent results with the legacy payroll system and meets the exit criteria required for go-live approval.

Parallel Payroll Testing (Should Employee Central Payroll be in Scope)

Parallel payroll testing is the process of verifying that a new SAP SuccessFactors Employee Central Payroll system produces consistent results with the legacy payroll system it is replacing.

Watch the video to learn about the cycles and goals involved in parallel payroll testing.

Key Points from Video
  • Confidence Through Parallel Testing — Parallel payroll testing provides confidence in the design and configuration of the new payroll system, serving as a critical input into the go/no-go decision for production deployment.

  • Multi-Cycle Testing Approach — Customers typically conduct 2-3 parallel payroll testing cycles, with each cycle building on the findings of the previous one to progressively validate and refine the system.

  • First Cycle – Data and Calculation Validation — The initial parallel run focuses on validating data migration and verifying basic payroll calculations, with a target of achieving approximately 85 percent employee match on net pay.

  • Second Cycle – Error Resolution and Refinement — The second testing cycle expands scope to address configuration errors, data mapping issues, and discrepancies identified during the first cycle, driving the match rate closer to the final benchmark.

  • Final Cycle – Full Production Readiness — The concluding validation cycle involves a complete parallel run using full production data, with the goal of achieving a 99 percent employee match on net pay as the standard for go-live readiness.

To conduct parallel payroll testing:

  • All system configuration must be complete with all workbooks signed off and implemented.

  • Production snapshot of SAP HCM must be taken just prior to payroll execution with parallel snapshot date including most common (high volume) and most complicated pay groups.

  • QA environment must be refreshed and loaded with latest production data, with configuration (H/W, software, Platform, Cluster, etc.) 100% equal to Production environment.

  • Master data must be loaded and initial simulation run must be executed to test data is successfully loaded.

Core Testing Activities of Parallel Payroll Testing

Core testing activities include:

  • Test Data Preparation: Execute simulation run to check for exceptions and resolve system roadblocks for initial master data upload, obtain year-to-date (YTD) converted data from legacy system and perform sanity checks.

  • Parallel Run Execution: Perform live run of different payroll frequencies (Weekly/Semi-Monthly/Monthly) using production data on actual dates of pay cycles.

  • Results Comparison and Analysis: Compare SAP payroll results with legacy system using payroll comparison programs or tools to identify data differences between Payroll Parallel Test client and Production Control client.

Comparison and Validation Process

The comparison and validation process involves:

  • Manual comparison and automated comparison tools for payroll results between legacy and SAP systems.

  • Payroll comparison programs to identify data differences using recommended difference classifications.

  • External validation tools (e.g., www.paycheckcity.com) for deviations that cannot be justified internally.

  • Final testing step compares payroll posting results to relevant financial systems.

Issue Management of Parallel Payroll Testing

The common testing challenges include:

  • Data migration errors including invalid field values, dates, format, or signs.

  • Configuration errors requiring changes to schemas, rules, wage types, and other payroll configuration.

  • Mapping errors in comparison methodology requiring re-calibration.

Resolution Process

  • Resolve deviations and perform root cause analysis for all identified variances.

  • Get agreement with project and service delivery team if deviations are correct and obtain sign-off.

  • Fix deviations with SAP payroll system and re-run next parallel cycle.

  • Involve labor relations and business process owners to interpret deviations which cannot be resolved by external engines.

Sample Success Criteria

  • 99% of employees matching on net pay as final exit criterion.

  • All high and medium priority defects are fixed, retested, and closed.

  • Minimize parallel payroll exceptions between SAP Payroll and legacy with consecutive parallel runs until exceptions reach targeted percentage.

  • Business stakeholder sign-off confirming payroll accuracy and production readiness.

Case Study: How Pinnacle Industries Conducted Parallel Payroll Testing

Payroll accuracy was Pinnacle Industries’ most sensitive go-live concern. With 15,000 employees across multiple countries and complex payroll rules, the HR Director insisted on three full parallel cycles before approving go-live. The payroll testing lead coordinated closely with both the legacy payroll team and the new SAP SuccessFactors configuration team throughout the process.

Key Activities

  • Executed Cycle 1 with full production payroll data, achieving an 83% net pay match — slightly below target due to a retroactive pay configuration error.

  • Resolved the retroactive pay issue and 14 additional configuration items between Cycle 1 and Cycle 2.

  • Executed Cycle 2, achieving a 93% net pay match and confirming that all high-value employee records were calculating correctly.

  • Executed the Final Validation Cycle with complete production data, achieving a 99.2% net pay match — exceeding the 99% exit criterion.

  • Documented all variance investigations and resolution steps for the external audit record.

Outcome

Pinnacle Industries obtained formal payroll go-live approval from the CFO and HR Director, with:

  • A 99.2% net pay match rate providing the confidence needed for the go/no-go decision.

  • Complete documentation of all payroll variances and their resolutions.

  • A validated payroll configuration ready for production deployment at go-live.

Summary

  • Testing Approach and Cycles: Parallel payroll testing validates that the new SAP SuccessFactors Employee Central Payroll system produces consistent results with the legacy system through 2-3 testing cycles, progressing from initial data migration validation (85% employee match) through expanded configuration testing to final validation achieving 99% employee match on net pay.

  • Pre-Testing Requirements and Setup: System configuration must be fully completed with signed-off workbooks, production data snapshot captured prior to payroll execution, QA environment refreshed with production data and configured identically to production specifications, and master data successfully loaded with initial simulation runs executed.

  • Core Testing Activities: Testing encompasses test data preparation with simulation runs and YTD data validation, parallel run execution using production data across different payroll frequencies on actual pay cycle dates, and comprehensive results comparison using both manual and automated payroll comparison tools supplemented by external validation engines.

  • Issue Resolution and Quality Standards: Common challenges including data migration errors, configuration errors, and mapping discrepancies are resolved through root cause analysis, cross-functional team agreement, system fixes, and re-execution of parallel cycles, with final success criteria requiring 99% employee net pay matching, all high and medium priority defects closed, and business stakeholder sign-off confirming production readiness.