Outlining Planning Methods

Objective

After completing this lesson, you will be able to plan in profitability analysis with manual and automatic methods

Manual Planning

Diagram showing sections titled Planning Level, Planning Package, Planning Method, and Parameter Set, showing regions for various events and professional segments, including an icon of people raising hands.

Planning in CO-PA can be executed on several levels. These levels include product group and product level, customer level, and product level. You can also plan on any profitability segment in CO-PA.

The system ensures that data remains consistent across all levels throughout the planning process. Although changes are made on various levels during the planning process, the values from these levels are reconcilable because the subtotals of these levels add up to totals.

For example, you can enter planned quantities at customer or product level for two customers and three products. Then, by definition, the total by product equals the customer or product information. If additions are made at the product level, the additions are displayed at the customer or product level with an unassigned customer.

The system automatically performs derivation in the background when the plan data is saved. As a result, the values planned under one or more characteristic values are also automatically summarized under other higher-level characteristics.

For example, you can add the product group characteristic to the operating concern. When you plan at the product level, the values are automatically rolled up under the appropriate product groups, although no product group was specified while entering the plan data. This roll-up happens automatically at every location where the derivation occurs.

Defining a Planning Layout

Diagram showing a planning layout with a header labeled Header: General data selection and three sections below labeled Lead columns, Data columns, and Attributes.

Planning layouts are customized screens for entering plan data. The definition of a planning layout controls the appearance of the Planning screen and some of its functions. This allows complete flexibility in controlling the planning entry process.

A planning layout definition consists of the following parts:

  • General data selection:

    In this part, you specify the characteristic values that are valid for the entire layout. For example, if you do not want to display actual data beside the plan data, you can set the plan-actual-indicator in the general data selection. Otherwise, you need that characteristic in the specific column.

  • Lead columns:

    In these columns, you specify characteristic or value field combinations. For example, the characteristic might be "Customer". However, you do not want to plan data for all customer numbers specified in the planning level, but only the specific customer numbers you enter in the lead column on a specific row.

Note

If you want to define a form with a characteristic hierarchy, you put this characteristic in the lead column. The data columns contain values such as the current plan data and the previous year’s plan data. If you want to define a detail form with one row for each value field and several different value fields, you assign the value fields to the lead column.

Each row and column intersection in a planning layout definition requires valid values for the special characteristics version, record type (for costing-based CO-PA), and the plan or actual indicator. When these values are employed in the layout design, layouts can be created in which the values can be planned for multiple versions at a time. Employing these values in the layout design also means that history data can be displayed for reference.

You can use variables when defining planning layouts to give them maximum flexibility. Variables can be used for any characteristic and they can be installed in rows, columns, or the general data selection. Users are prompted to enter the values for these variables when planning.

Separate planning layouts are required for costing-based CO-PA and Margin Analysis. This is because planning figures on the two sides of CO-PA are not related or linked.

When defining layouts in costing-based CO-PA, the characteristic record type is necessary.

Defining a Planning Layout (2)

Image showing Sales organization showing period, record type, version, customer, product, quantity, revenue, and COGS. Includes planning levels, package, parameter group, and steps for creating planning layout.

A general planning layout that corresponds to the selections made in the plan level and package can be created automatically. Specific layout features can be maintained manually.

The basic options for defining the lead columns are as follows:

  • Each row in the lead column can be defined separately and consists of a combination of characteristic values. In this case, the columns are value columns. Alternatively, each row can be a value row, in which case the columns are characteristic values.

  • The entire lead column can be selected to represent a characteristic, in which case the columns are value columns. If you use this option, you can obtain multiple lead columns but you cannot hard-code any rows.

Value columns are defined using characteristics, value fields, attributes, and formulas. If the lead column contains only characteristics, each value column must at least contain a value field. The column can also contain characteristic values pertaining to the value field.

The following attributes can be tagged to each value column:

  • A distribution key for distributing the summarized values to periods

  • A unit for the value field (either a currency or a unit)

  • A long text indicator (indicating that long text can exist)

  • All characteristics

Planning Variables

Screenshot showing SAP Planning Framework overview showing a process to define a variable with selection criteria for Period/Year, and corresponding variables displayed. Labels highlight Define Variable and Select Variable.

You can define the variables for your planning levels and planning packages.

For example, you can use a variable instead of a planning package to specify the planning period.

You can use all the planning packages for planning runs in subsequent fiscal years without the need to change each planning package. Instead, you can change the characteristic of the variable centrally.

You can maintain variables directly from the Planning screen by choosing EditVariable.

Planning Methods

Fowchart showing a planning process: Step 1 - Planning target values, Step 2 - Break-down of target values, Step 3 - Analytical distribution planning, Step 4 - Integrated transfer of planning data. After verifying objectives, the process leads to Step 5 - Transfer to production planning. Simulation is shown influencing Step 2.

The figure, Typical Phases in Sales Planning, shows an example of one possible integrated process for sales and profit planning.

The sales planning process consists of the following phases:

  1. Planning of target values (for example, at material group level): You can determine average prices and cost of goods manufactured at this stage.
  2. Top-down distribution of plan data: The plan data for material groups is broken down into combinations of customer groups and products.
  3. Manual entering of plan data for each sales representative in bottom-up planning: This can then be combined in a single plan version.
  4. Transferal of additional plan data to sales and profit planning from other business areas, such as Cost Center Accounting (CO-CCA) or incoming orders
  5. Finalization of planning and transferal of plan data to production planning: This allows production plan data to be reconciled with sales planning.

Planning Target Values

Image showing planning target values methods: calculate average prices/costs, manual revision of plan values, planning/simulating target values using simplification by ratios, manual planning, goal seek function.

At the start of the first planning phase, in which you plan target values, you define average prices and the cost of goods manufactured. Introducing ratios helps simplify planning prices manually. With the Goal Seek function, you can enter the target revenue, and the system calculates the planned price required to attain it.

Planning with Ratios

Diagram showing value assignment process. The current plan includes sales quantity, price, and revenue, which are used to compute plan data like revenue and sales quantity, categorized as VV010 (Revenue) and VVIQT (Sales Qty).

A ratio is a quotient involving two value fields, such as price = sales/quantity. Ratios can be used as a basis for simulating corresponding adjustments and alterations of quantities and prices in the planning layout.

You can define ratios centrally in Customizing. They can be selected in the same way as normal value fields when you define the planning layout.

Ratios or prices are not saved on the database. Instead, they are calculated dynamically from the quantities and values at each planning level. This helps to avoid the buildup of redundant data and ensure a consistent dataset.

Planning with a Ratio Scheme

Image comparing planned sales quantities and revenues for three sales groups in the current year against actual prices from the previous year. The ratio M1 is defined as sales revenue divided by sales quantity.

Ratios are summarized in a ratio scheme. You can apply these schemes against existing plan data. This is done to valuate the existing plan base values with ratio values, or the rates calculated based on specific reference data. The reference data can be the actual data or data from another planning version. For example, if a ratio scheme contains a ratio for per-unit price, you can use a ratio scheme to valuate a sales quantity plan and determine the price for each piece from the actual data.

You can use ratio schemes in both manual and automatic planning. In manual and automatic planning, you can indicate the ratio scheme and reference data (plan data or actual data, plan version, record type, and reference time interval). In automatic planning, you can apply ratio schemes using the Copy and Change functions.

Reaching Objectives Using Goal Seek

Image showing a person riding a bike with sales data for two products (T-F100 and T-F101) showing quantities, prices, and revenues. T-F101 exceeds the target sales revenue of 120,000.

You can perform data simulations in planning using the Goal Seek function. This function allows you to enter a target contribution margin in manual planning, and enables the system to calculate the corresponding quantity sold.

To use Goal Seek, both sides of the relevant data cells must be mathematically inclined, that is, as a formula or as a ratio. In the figure, Reaching Objectives Using Goal Seek, ratios that are hidden in the layout create the relationship between the contribution margin and the quantity sold. To use Goal Seek, first select the two relevant data cells and choose EditGoal Seek.

Enter a target value in the dialog box that appears, such as a revenue of 120,000. The system then calculates the appropriate quantity, which in this case is 6,000 items.

Manual Planning CO-PA Costing-Based

Business Example

For the implementation of profitability analysis, the managers have the following requirements:

  • Use the CO-PA module to plan the sales of the two main product lines of the company, mountain bicycles and racing bicycles. You want to plan the sales for market segments defined by customer and product. You want to plan the sales quantities and selling prices. The system should calculate the plan revenue. With another plan, you want to plan the sales by product group and then you want to perform a top-down distribution from product group to product using actual data of the products as an allocation basis.
  • The product managers would like to perform what-if analysis on the plan data. For example, they might want to analyze the effect that pricing increases could have on revenue.
  • The production planning team wants to use the projected sales quantities from CO-PA to plan the production and material procurement schedules. They want to have access to the CO-PA plan values using in Sales Operation Planning (SOP). For this reason, planning quantities, prices, and revenue at customer and product level are required.

Planning at the product group level is required with the systematic distribution of values to the product level. Mass changes to plan values are required to analyze different business scenarios. Transferring CO-PA plan data to SOP is required to aid production scheduling. For this purpose, you need to know the profit planning process and the phases in sales planning.

Task 1: Create a New Plan Version

Task 2: Create a Planning Layout

Your sales managers have asked you to create the Planning layout as shown in the following table. This allows each sales rep to enter the top products and customers using version 5##, the current fiscal year, and the sales organization 1010.

Planning Layout

CustomerProductInvoiced quantityRevenuePrice
__________________________________________________________________________________________

Task 3: Plan Customer Values

Top-Down Distribution

Image showing Breakdown of target values with three sections: Determining the distribution method, Receiver characteristic, and Reference Data. Parameters section showing three checkboxes: non-assigned, assigned, and actual vs. plan.

You can use an extensive top-down distribution function, available in manual and automatic planning, for the second planning phase. This involves the top-down distribution of the target values to an extensive planning level.

Top-Down Distribution in Planning

Image describing distribution of values: Plan values undergo tracing factors producing results as distributed values. Methods include non-assigned values and total value, illustrated by an arrow loop.

Top-down distribution is a process for distributing data that has been planned at one level in CO-PA to the additional levels based on reference data. Reference data can be plan or actual CO-PA data. Top-down distribution can only be used in automatic planning.

An example of top-down distribution is planning values at product group level, and then distributing these values to the individual products in a group. Another example is planning values at product level, and then distributing these values to the plants from which the products are sold.

Plan values can be distributed strictly according to the reference data by period or the reference data aggregated across periods. Reference data aggregated across periods equalizes the distribution percentages across periods for the receivers.

When performing a top-down distribution, you specify the field or fields in the reference data. The values of the reference data field or fields are used as the reference base.

The options for specifying fields in the reference data during top-down distribution are as follows:

  • Fixed value fields:

    The data of all value fields is distributed according to the distribution of values of this value field.

  • All value fields:

    The data of each value field is distributed according to the relative reference data for each profitability segment for the same value field.

Method: Distributing Unassigned Values

Top-down distribution enables you to distribute the data from a higher planning level to lower levels. For example, you can perform planning at the product group level and distribute the values to the product level.

The plan data is distributed in the same way as the existing reference data. With top-down distribution, you can use plan or actual data as reference data and you can distribute the data separately by period or aggregate the values over several periods to level out fluctuations.

In the figure, Method: Distributing Unassigned Values, the unassigned plan data (value 1000) at the product group level is distributed to the individual products in the same way as the base values (the actual quantities sold). This distribution is at a ratio of 3:2.

The product group is credited with 1000, and the products are debited with 600 (product A1) and 400 (product A2). We assume the initial plan for each pump was 1000 a piece.

Method: Distributing Total Values

Diagram showing the distribution of unassigned revenue based on product quantity. It starts with plan values, identifies unassigned revenue to be distributed using a tracing factor, and shows the final distributed values.

In the figure, Method: Distributing Total Values, the sum of the plan data for the product group is the individual values of the products (each prior value) and the unassigned values (value #) at the product group level. The sum is distributed to the individual products in the same way as the base values (actual quantities sold ), which is at a ratio of 3:2. The product group is credited and the products are debited.

Automatic Planning – Top-Down Distribution

Image showing the Planning Framework: Overview screen in an application with steps labeled: Define parameters for top-down distribution, define top-down logic, define senders and receiver, select reference data.

In the parameter set, you can choose between the following top-down methods that define what values are to be distributed:

  • Using the Only Distribute Unassigned method, you can distribute only values that are posted directly at the higher level.

  • Using the Distribute Total Value method, you can distribute all the values located at the higher level, regardless of whether they were posted there directly or rolled up from more extensive levels. When you use this method, the values taken from the extensive level are overwritten by the new distributed value.

You specify the receiver characteristic for the distribution under Receiver Characteristic. You can select several characteristics from the characteristics specified in the planning level.

In the Reference value field, you can enter a specific value field for the reference data or a key figure calculated from value fields, as the basis for distribution. Alternatively, you can specify that the distribution occurs according to value fields. In this way, each value field is taken as the basis for its distribution.

You can select Cumulative Periods to smooth out incidental differences that occurred from period to period in the reference data.

You specify the time frame for the reference data used as the basis for executing the planning method.

Automatic Planning – Top-Down Distribution (2)

Screenshot showing planning framework software displaying selected and available value fields, such as Sales quantity, within a highlighted section. Tooltip reads Choose value fields with arrow pointing to value field options.

You can specify the following settings in the parameter set:

  • Specify whether the data to be used as the reference data is the actual data, the data from the plan version for the planning package, or data from a different plan version that is yet to be specified.

  • Specify for a sender characteristic that a different characteristic value in the reference data forms the basis for distribution. That is, the distribution of the product groups for the product data of country 1 is executed based on the product data of country 2. To do this, use the Transform Characteristic Values function.

  • Specify whether the planning method is to be executed in a test run or in an update run, or whether this decision is to be postponed until the execution of the parameter set.

  • Specify whether to jump to a background processing screen.

  • Specify the value fields that are to be distributed on the Value fields tab page.

Perform a Top-Down Distribution

Business Example

Your planners want to plan at the Product Group level and distribute the plan values to Product based on the actual sales data for products. Because of this, you need to conduct a top-down planning run.

Plan miscellaneous sales quantities and revenues for material group L004 in version 5##. Then distribute these planned values top-down based on the actual sales quantities posted in the previous year.

Bottom-Up Planning

Image ishowing analytical sales planning in SAP System, featuring manual planning processes, Excel data integration, various planning methods, and evaluation of planning quantities with prices and costs.

In the third planning phase, plan values are planned bottom-up, and the merging of plan values can occur in several steps. For example, the default plan values can be created automatically (copied or revaluated) and then used as a plan basis for individual sales representatives.

Integrated Microsoft Excel allows sales representatives to create their sales plan data locally.

Finally, the individual plans can be merged into a single version and valuated with the operative prices and costs of goods manufactured.

Bottom-Up Planning: Example

Image showing a hierarchical breakdown of sales quantity. Starting with a total of 4000 Racing Bikes in the 1010 Sales organization, subdivided into 1000 by Washington, 2000 by Smith, and 1000 by Redford for Smith SE.

In bottom-up planning, plan data is created at the customer and the product group levels and aggregated to corresponding higher levels.

Excel Integration

Screenshot showing decentralized data entry in Excel integrated with SAP S/4. Users can embed and upload Excel files for flexible data handling, planning levels, profit analysis, file description, and layout maintenance.

The integration of Microsoft Excel into profit planning allows you to use Microsoft Excel functions. These include functions for additional calculations, graphics, and printing. The SAP system ensures the consistency of the data centrally, by providing central functions such as derivation and valuation.

To perform local planning, save the Microsoft Excel sheets created in the SAP system locally on a PC, and then work on them in Excel outside the SAP environment. The data can be uploaded to the SAP system later using the Flexible Upload function.

How to Plan with Excel

Evaluate Additional Planning Functions

Diagram showing the process of planning using reference data from actual previous year and previous year's plan. Various planning methods include Copy, Forecast, and Top-down distribution to generate Plan Version 2.

You can use automatic planning functions to process a large number of profitability segments simultaneously. You can execute these functions online or in the background, but they require authorization for use.

When using automatic planning, specifying the characteristics and value fields that you want to process allows you to set the planning scope in each case.

Automatic planning functions are included in the concept of planning levels and planning packages.

There are twelve planning methods from which you can select the characteristics to be planned at the planning level and in the planning package. Enter all other settings and select the value fields in a parameter set for the corresponding planning method, such as Copy.

The Planning Management function keeps track of the automatic planning functions that were executed and the user who executed these functions. This function also provides a complete log of mass changes made to plan data, the log information as to when certain functions were performed, who performed them, and what profitability segments were changed.

Copying Plan Data

Diagram comparing previous year's actual data to target for sales, revenue, and quantity by group. The settings box includes basic settings, processing instructions, selection criteria, and choose value.

In the target fields, specify the following information:

  • The posting periods to be updated with the copied data

  • The plan version to be updated

  • The record type under which the plan data is to be saved

In the source fields, specify the following information:

  • The posting periods from which data is to be copied

  • The plan version from which the data is to be copied (if copying plan data)

  • The record type of the plan data you want to copy

  • The plan/actual indicator

Specify a distribution key to summarize the source data for all the periods and then distribute them across the target periods. If you leave the Distribution key field blank, the values are copied directly from the source periods to the target periods.

If you want the system to automatically perform valuation during the copy process, select the Valuate radio button. Target value fields can then be populated with values from costing sheets, product costing, and user exits.

Specify whether the source data should overwrite, add to, or subtract from the existing data in the target plan version.

Copying Plan Data: Transformation of Characteristics

Image of table comparing reference data, transformation, and operating profit for two customers. Cust. 1 has 1,000 units, Cust. 2 has 2,000 units. Operating profit options include: do not add/cancel, add/cancel, add/do not cancel.

Add and Post options have been added to characteristic transformation.

When using the Add function, the copied values are added to the existing recipient characteristics.

When Add is not selected, the copied values overwrite the existing plan data in the recipient characteristic.

When you select the Clear indicator, the values in the original characteristic are removed.

Forecasting

Image showing moving average forecast profile and strategy using data from the previous 5 periods of actual revenue. Source data includes values from periods 08/yy to 12/yy. Forecast data for 01/yy+1 is 110.

You can use the forecasting function to automatically calculate new plan data using existing data and customizable forecast profiles. You can use forecasting in manual and in automatic planning.

A forecast profile is a combination of a forecast model delivered by SAP and a set of user-defined parameters.

You can create forecast profiles in the CO-PA user menu. The SAP system supports a number of predefined forecast models, including trend models, seasonal models, and exponential models.

Weighting groups may be required as a parameter for the forecast profile, depending on the model you have selected. Weighting groups are also created in the CO-PA application menu.

With manual planning, you make a forecast by selecting a value or a column, and then choosing the Forecast function. Enter the required parameters, such as the forecast period and the reference data to be used, in the dialog box.

To forecast with automatic planning, choose Automatic PlanningForecast in the application menu. Then, enter a forecast profile and the required parameters on the initial screen.

Planning Sequences

Screenshot of the Planning Framework Overview in a software interface. It displays navigation options, planning levels, methods, and parameters. The planning sequence includes top-down distribution and revaluation tasks.

You can use planning sequences to combine, sort, and execute several automatic planning methods in one run. For example, first copy the plan values, distribute them using the top-down method, and then revaluate them.

Integrated Transfer of Plan Data

Image showing integrated transfer of plan data with three steps: Transfer of cost center costs, settle order and project plans, transfer plan sales quantity to SOP. Methods in SAP include allocations for overhead costs, planned settlement of orders, integration into SOP.

In the fifth planning phase, you complete your sales and profit planning data with the additional plan data from other application components.

Integration of Planning

Diagram showing data flow from cost center, process, internal orders, and projects into a central cube, representing data integration in an organizational structure. Labeled CO, PS, OVH, and PA.

The SAP system supports integrated planning in Controlling (CO). Although planning is conducted separately for multiple business activities in CO, the  plans are linked to ensure consistency and drive realistic corporate-wide planning. As a result, the planning results for sales, service, production, procurement, general, and administration activities coincide to form one corporate operational plan.

The integration of multiple plans is accomplished in the SAP system through real-time and periodic synchronization of the data in the plan versions across modules. For example, the sales quantities planned in the Sales Information System (SIS) may be transferred in batch to the Sales and Operation Planning (SOP). SOP then uses the information to generate the necessary planned production and procurement activities. This example can be integrated with the overhead plans in CO-CCA, and the end results can be passed to CO-PA, where the resulting overall profitability plan resides.

The flow of planning data is one of the many possible planning strategies that can be used in the SAP system. The flow used for a given company depends on many factors, such as the modules being implemented, the planning functions in those modules, the integration functions between the modules, and the maintenance steps necessary to achieve integration.

Cost Center Assessment

Image showing Cost center for 'Administration' lists amounts for material (20,000), 3rd party (30,000), and assessment (-50,000). Arrow labeled Planning Cycle points to cube labeled CO PA with final margin analysis being +50,000.

To reflect plan costs from CO-CCA in CO-PA, transfer those costs into the CO-PA portion of a plan version through a cost center assessment. With this tool, planned costs can be allocated across profitability segments in the same way that actual costs can be allocated across profitability segments.

To assess cost center costs in CO-PA, an assessment cycle must first be defined. The assessment cycle consists of a series of segments, each of which defines a unique relationship between senders, receivers, and assessment rules. These segments can be defined on the user side of CO-PA.

When assessment cycles are defined, you must specify the controlling area from which the assessment takes place. This is because the allocations in Management Accounting can only take place within a single controlling area.

When allocating in CO-PA, it is not possible to exceed controlling areas. The controlling area is one part of the definition of the receiver’s operating concern.

You must specify the side of CO-PA from which the tracing factors should be drawn. These tracing factors are for an assessment rule for which variable portions are defined. This setting controls whether values are distributed based on account balances for profitability segments or key figure amounts for profitability segments.

Assessments affect both costing-based CO-PA and account-based CO-PA, if both are active. This is necessary from an SAP costing perspective because costs are being moved from the originating account assignment objects and cost centers. They are then being placed on the receiving objects and profitability segments, which are shared between both sides of CO-PA.

How to Use the Integration Functionality

Demonstrate integrated planning.

Summary

  • Manual planning in CO-PA can be executed at various levels, ensuring data consistency.

  • Planning sequences combine multiple planning methods for efficient execution.

  • Top-down distribution allocates planned values from higher to lower levels.

  • Bottom-up planning aggregates plan data from customer and product levels.

  • Integrated transfer of plan data ensures consistency across SAP modules.